Reviews

Sunrise on the Reaping

3.5 out of 5 stars

An entertaining return to Panem that comes close to Catching Fire

In the year 2012, my dad and I made a deal. Third-grade me could see the new Hunger Games movie with my older siblings, but because of the mature themes, I had to read the book first. So read I did, and I flew through the series. As my classmates started to pick up the books as well, it was the first time I remember a craze really taking over in my life. During school recess, we played Hunger Games; during reading time, Hunger Games; Halloween, Hunger Games. It was everywhere, and through all the craze, there was a throwaway line in book one that captivated me like no other. A tease of Haymitch’s games, the second quarter quell, where there were twice as many tributes. Ever since, fans have been dying to see Haymitch’s story come to life. So in 2024, when there was not only a book announced, but a movie adaptation of Haymitch’s games as well, it was hard not to be excited. As with other book-to-movie adaptations, I have read the book and will reference it occasionally, but this is a review of the movie on its own, not a judgment of how well the book is adapted. 

Where better to start than this cast? Because wow, is it stacked. At the center is Joseph Zada, an Australian actor who looks the part and is doing his very best Appalachian accent. His performance is never outright bad, but with all the talent around him, he definitely leaves the most to be desired. Especially with how demanding the role is. McKenna Grace was probably the standout among the newcomers, delivering some of the most humorous and heartfelt moments of the movie. Kieran Culkin is doing his best to beat the typecast allegations, and it’s hilarious throughout. As for casting younger versions of characters we’ve come to know and love, it doesn’t get much better than this. Maya Hawke, Jesse Plemons, Kieran Culkin, Elle Fanning, Kelvin Harrison Jr., Lili Taylor, and Ralph Fiennes round out an incredible ensemble. While their physical resemblance ranges from almost identical to loose resemblance, the performances capture these familiar characters so well.

Haymitch’s story was always so intriguing for two main reasons. First, how in the world did this alcoholic beat 47 other tributes to win his games? And second, what made him so miserable? Fortunately, Sunrise on the Reaping’s strongest writing centers on answering those two questions. For a runtime of 2 hours and 47 minutes, this movie flies by, largely thanks to its rapid pacing. With audiences already familiar with much of the world and its characters, the movie can spend less time on setup and more time exploring Haymitch’s story. It jumps from one idea to the next very quickly, sometimes to a detriment, but it certainly isn’t boring. When adapting a book to a movie, it just isn’t possible to fit everything into a reasonable runtime, and SOTR does a good job of keeping the important bits. But this rapid pace, while entertaining, does leave little time to let things breathe, and this constant string of tragedies starts to feel repetitive toward the end. For a backstory about how a man became so broken, the suffering is necessary, but it would have been nice to have this tragedy be more focused at times.

This is never more apparent than the games themselves. They’re still some of the strongest moments in the movie, even if it doesn’t quite reach the heights of Catching Fire. CinemaSins has undoubtedly done irreparable damage to the movie-watching experience, and nitpicking will ruin even the best of movies. But there’s a difference between looking for problems and having them pull you out of the story. Sunrise on the Reaping occasionally falls into the latter category, with questionable character decisions and convenient developments that are hard to ignore. Whether it’s a problem with the script or the editing is hard to say, but spectacle can only cover up so much. When the games are working, it’s some of the best stuff in the franchise, which makes the little things holding it back frustrating. 

When you think of YA novel adaptations, Hunger Games is kinda the gold standard, and for good reason. These movies have always looked great, and Sunrise on the Reaping is no exception. This time around, the arena almost feels like it was designed to be seen in IMAX, even if there are a few moments that could have been touched up. If a movie about children being forced to fight for food can have this much beautiful color in it, there’s no excuse for the grey sludge infecting Hollywood right now (Looking at you, HBO Harry Potter). The production design is impressive as ever. It’s a crime that this may be the only time we get to see some of these sets because they were a blast to be in. Everything in the Capitol is so bright and vibrant, while even the bleakness of District 12 is visually compelling thanks to some creative lens choices. The soundtrack is pretty traditional Hunger Games, which isn’t a bad thing, as the Capitol theme will never get old.

Francis Lawrence has now directed five of these movies, and it might as well be six, as 2025’s The Long Walk is spiritually a Hunger Games movie. As of right now, there are no plans for another movie, and with Lawrence signing on to direct the upcoming Red Rising adaptation, this may be the last time Panem makes an appearance on the big screen for some time. If that’s the case, Sunrise on the Reaping accomplishes what it sets out to do. It’s a very entertaining blockbuster, packed with moments book fans will love, and a genuinely tragic backstory that gives more weight to a fan favorite character. Fourteen years later, it was worth the wait, but it’s frustrating that some questionable writing and rushed storytelling keep Sunrise on the Reaping from really catching fire. 

Comments

Comments are for subscribers. Free subscription. No payment, ever.

Subscribe free Sign in